Thread of holocaust denial Options

[Mitchell]

[dice]

if that list's any indication it was a shitty year for music

[arkin]

if that list's any indication it was a shitty year for music

It wasn't. You can't really use a Q list as the basis for the quality of music out there or else we all would have given up long ago.

Btw, it's October. Too early blah blah blah blah

Kasabian? Maybe they were the ones that gave up.

[Liffey]

yay, list time

There's not much on my radar for the next two months, although I haven't listened to half the stuff on Ringo's list. The order of these will probably change a little by the end of the year, but I'm pretty happy with it at this point. Been a great year for sure.

50) Zu - Carboniferous
49) Bibio - Ambulence Avenue
48) Club of the Sons - Young Quanta
47) Yeah Yeah Yeahs - It's Blitz!
46) Franz Ferdinand - Tonight: Franz Ferdinand
45) Paper Route - Absence
44) Califone - All My Friends Are Funeral Singers
43) Future of the Left - Travels With Myself and Another
42) Mono - Hymn to the Immortal Wind
41) Sir Richard Bishop - The Freak of Araby
40) Nels Cline - Coward
39) St. Vincent - Actor
38) Dredg - The Pariah, The Pharoah, The Delusion
37) Allen Toussaint - The Bright Mississippi
36) M. Ward - Hold Time
35) Mos Def - The Ecstatic
34) The Horrors - Primary Colours
33) The Field - Yesterday and Today
32) Karl Sanders - Saurian Exorcisms
31) Akron/Family - Set 'Em Wild, Set 'Em Free
30) Exivious - Exivious
29) Tyondai Braxton - Central Market
28) Giuseppe Ielasi - Aix
27) IAMX - Kingdom of the Welcome Addiction
26) OOIOO - ARMONICO HEWA
25) Yo La Tengo - Popular Songs
24) Black Cock - Robot Child with a God Complex
23) A Sunny Day In Glasglo - Ashes Grammar
22) Animals as Leaders - Animals as Leaders
21) The Dream - Love vs Money
20) Joe Henry - Blood from the Stars
19) Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
18) Andrew Bird - Noble Beast
17) Fever Ray - Fever Ray
16) Grizzly Bear - Veckatimist
15) The Dirty Projectors - Bitte Orca
14) James Blackshaw - The Glass Bead Game
13) Maudlin of the Well - Part the Second
12) Ametsub - The Nothings of the North
11) The Decemberists - The Hazards of Love
10) Arve Henriksen - Cartography
9) fun. - Aim & Ignite
8) Mastodon - Crack the Skye
7) Hecq - Steeltongued
6) The Antlers - Hospice
5) mewithoutyou - It's All Crazy! It's All False! I't's All a Dream! It's Alright
4) Kormorany - La Musica Teatrale
3) Mew - No More Stories
2) The Flaming Lips - Embryonic
1) Animal Collective - Merriweather Post Pavillion

[Mitchell]

Liffey, are you a recognized music magazine?

No, I didn't think so.

[Liffey]

watchoo talkin bout, I've got all kinds of stuff on there you won't find on p4k.

[Raj (Noble Con)]

Apparently Mitch didn't learn from his last misadventure in threadtitling.

Had to go with the vague bullshit subtitle instead of an all-caps "this thread is for publication lists, not your personal lists or SOMB EOY voting."

[Raj (Noble Con)]

Not that I'm absolving Liffey here by any means.

Q Top 50 Albums 2009

Ringo's list

:wat:

[Eskimo Kisses]

My case file against Liffey is growing by the fucking hour.

[spiritofeden]

Hey Liffey.

start a fish thread for your list.

[Mitchell]

Apparently Mitch didn't learn from his last misadventure in threadtitling.

Had to go with the vague bullshit subtitle instead of an all-caps "this thread is for publication lists, not your personal lists or SOMB EOY voting."

True, the last two years the average intelligence of the board was at a level that didn't need these things spelt out. Good job I can edit thread titles.

[Liffey]

So you're saying that my list sucks because there are evidently some other publications out there who cover these albums (I wouldn't know, the only publication I read is p4k, and that's only to check for reviews of albums I've already listened to). Do I have a responsibility to keep track of what the magazines are covering, just for the sake of not listening to that stuff? Am I supposed to be sitting here cataloging p4k reviews to make sure I don't happen to like an album that they also liked? Am I not allowed to listen to what the fuck I want to listen to, regardless of how popular it gets?

Furthermore: Just look at the threads on SOMB. I see Animal Collective, Phoenix, Grizzly Bear and Dirty Projectors threads. Or look at the SOMB year end polls. Last year you, the highly sophisticated and elite S.O.M.B. chose these as your favorite albums of the year:
Portishead - Third
TV On The Radio - Dear Science,
M83 - Saturdays = Youth
Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Sun Kil Moon - April
Deerhunter - Microcastle / Weird Era Cont.
Cut Copy - In Ghost Colours
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
British Sea Power - Do You Like Rock Music?
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds

Fleet Foxes, TVotR and Bon Iver. I had Shugo Tokumaru, Have A Nice Life, Chris Wood and Helios. And I'm the one who gets bashed for not being obscure enough, or not having enough variety. Not that my choices are entirely unheard of, but compared to Fleet Foxes they are. And yes, I have Grizzly Bear and Animal Collective on my list as well. It's because I like they way they sound. But since a lot of other people happen to like the way they sound, I guess I'm not supposed to give those albums credit on my eoy list.

And actually you know what, I'm pretty damn sure there won't be a single aoty list from a major publication that includes any combination of Hecq, Kormorany, mewithoutYou, Arve Henriksen, IAMX, OOIOO, Black Cock, Nels Cline, Ametsub, Joe Henry, Club of the Sons, etc., etc. Not that I give a shit; I wouldn't mind in the least if my list were identical to p4k's. I don't feel any need to be a shining beacon of musical obscurity or variety. I just don't understand where people get off saying I'm more of a NAIR guy than anyone else.

Explain the situation to me.

[monotony]

Hey Liffey.

start a fish thread for your list.

We don't need any more Mew YSIs, thankyou.

In regards to the Q list, kudos for a bold and admirable placing of Florence and the Machine, but otherwise it's quite bewildering. Kasabian as AOTY? U2 in the top 10? Pearl Jam and Green Day? And for godsakes, Mika????!!! I mean, come on now. Really.

[Ogawa]

So you're saying that my list sucks because there are evidently some other publications out there who cover these albums (I wouldn't know, the only publication I read is p4k, and that's only to check for reviews of albums I've already listened to). Do I have a responsibility to keep track of what the magazines are covering, just for the sake of not listening to that stuff? Am I supposed to be sitting here cataloging p4k reviews to make sure I don't happen to like an album that they also liked? Am I not allowed to listen to what the fuck I want to listen to, regardless of how popular it gets?

Furthermore: Just look at the threads on SOMB. I see Animal Collective, Phoenix, Grizzly Bear and Dirty Projectors threads. Or look at the SOMB year end polls. Last year you, the highly sophisticated and elite S.O.M.B. chose these as your favorite albums of the year:
Portishead - Third
TV On The Radio - Dear Science,
M83 - Saturdays = Youth
Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Sun Kil Moon - April
Deerhunter - Microcastle / Weird Era Cont.
Cut Copy - In Ghost Colours
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
British Sea Power - Do You Like Rock Music?
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds

Fleet Foxes, TVotR and Bon Iver. I had Shugo Tokumaru, Have A Nice Life, Chris Wood and Helios. And I'm the one who gets bashed for not being obscure enough, or not having enough variety. Not that my choices are entirely unheard of, but compared to Fleet Foxes they are. And yes, I have Grizzly Bear and Animal Collective on my list as well. It's because I like they way they sound. But since a lot of other people happen to like the way they sound, I guess I'm not supposed to give those albums credit on my eoy list.

And actually you know what, I'm pretty damn sure there won't be a single aoty list from a major publication that includes any combination of Hecq, Kormorany, mewithoutYou, Arve Henriksen, IAMX, OOIOO, Black Cock, Nels Cline, Ametsub, Joe Henry, Club of the Sons, etc., etc. Not that I give a shit; I wouldn't mind in the least if my list were identical to p4k's. I don't feel any need to be a shining beacon of musical obscurity or variety. I just don't understand where people get off saying I'm more of a NAIR guy than anyone else.

Explain the situation to me.

[theremin]

How do I change the subtopic of a thread? I need to do a similar modification on the film version of this thread.

[demoncleaner]

Liffey... wow...

[monotony]

So you're saying that my list sucks because there are evidently some other publications out there who cover these albums (I wouldn't know, the only publication I read is p4k, and that's only to check for reviews of albums I've already listened to). Do I have a responsibility to keep track of what the magazines are covering, just for the sake of not listening to that stuff? Am I supposed to be sitting here cataloging p4k reviews to make sure I don't happen to like an album that they also liked? Am I not allowed to listen to what the fuck I want to listen to, regardless of how popular it gets?

Furthermore: Just look at the threads on SOMB. I see Animal Collective, Phoenix, Grizzly Bear and Dirty Projectors threads. Or look at the SOMB year end polls. Last year you, the highly sophisticated and elite S.O.M.B. chose these as your favorite albums of the year:
Portishead - Third
TV On The Radio - Dear Science,
M83 - Saturdays = Youth
Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Sun Kil Moon - April
Deerhunter - Microcastle / Weird Era Cont.
Cut Copy - In Ghost Colours
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
British Sea Power - Do You Like Rock Music?
Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds

Fleet Foxes, TVotR and Bon Iver. I had Shugo Tokumaru, Have A Nice Life, Chris Wood and Helios. And I'm the one who gets bashed for not being obscure enough, or not having enough variety. Not that my choices are entirely unheard of, but compared to Fleet Foxes they are. And yes, I have Grizzly Bear and Animal Collective on my list as well. It's because I like they way they sound. But since a lot of other people happen to like the way they sound, I guess I'm not supposed to give those albums credit on my eoy list.

And actually you know what, I'm pretty damn sure there won't be a single aoty list from a major publication that includes any combination of Hecq, Kormorany, mewithoutYou, Arve Henriksen, IAMX, OOIOO, Black Cock, Nels Cline, Ametsub, Joe Henry, Club of the Sons, etc., etc. Not that I give a shit; I wouldn't mind in the least if my list were identical to p4k's. I don't feel any need to be a shining beacon of musical obscurity or variety. I just don't understand where people get off saying I'm more of a NAIR guy than anyone else.

Explain the situation to me.

You have got this all wrong, Liffey. It's not your list itself that's the problem. It's the fact that you insist on posting it in virtually every thread.

[Liffey]

Liffey... wow...

That's another thing about this board. Half the posts are " " or one word, condescending replies.

If you're gonna bother posting, at least fucking say something.

You have got this all wrong, Liffey. It's not your list itself that's the problem. It's the fact that you insist on posting it in virtually every thread.

So this isn't the Rolling End of Year Lists 2009 Thread?

Seriously though, we've been over this a thousand times. I've posted in my list in like, three threads now. Out of over 1000 posts.

[monotony]

So this isn't the Rolling End of Year Lists 2009 Thread?

Seriously though, we've been over this a thousand times. I've post in my list in like, three threads now.

It's a Rolling End of Year Lists thread for magazines etc. IDK, Mitchell likes to do these sorts of things. Let him.

and you've posted your list in way more than three threads. I think most of us could recite your top 10 by heart.

[Liffey]

Now see if that had been stated from the start... I wouldn't have made a complete fool of myself

lol

this thread makes waaaaaay more sense now... sorry for fucking it up btw. I read the subtopic as just being an ass about my list.

edit: Wait. Magazines are already putting out their year end lists? Holy crap.