The Challenge:
My brother G and I selected 15 tracks that we thought our Mother would enjoy during our Thanksgiving road trip. Our brother A compiled and randomized the songs, replacing any duplicate selections with a track of his choosing. Mom graded each song on a scale of 0 to 5 (including half points). Highest total score wins. My mother likes Barry Manilow, Neal Diamond, The Beatles and Motown. She does not like things she describes as "quirky"
The Songs:
Mom's score follows each song title. G or K indicates selection. Running score totals are provided, along with number of tracks scored. Mom's comments are provided below each song.
G (left justified)
K (right justified)
1. Skinny Love - Bon Iver - 3 (G=3/1)
"I enjoyed the music more than the words (later: it sounded like guys trying to sing too high)."
2. Big Easy - Raphael Saadiq - 3.5 (K=3.5/1)
"motown-esque. I could understand the words"
3. As Tall as Cliffs - Margot & The Nuclear So & Sos - 3.5 (G=6.5/2)
"we haven't gotten to the very last note yet...i didn't like the end, the very end"
4. Awake My Soul - Mumford & Sons - 3 (K=6.5/2)
"Parts were a 2.5 and parts were a 3. I liked the instrumental more than the words"
5. Blue and Gold Print - Mates of State - 3 (K=9.5/3)
"All these songs are falling between the 2.5 - 3.0 range. It grew on me."
K in a note to G: "I think mom decided if she gives bad scores she won't have to do this again next year."
6. Another Day - Jamie Lidell - 5 (G=11.5/3)
"That was my favorite song so far. I understood the words and I liked the musicality (that's a big word on Dancing With The Stars)"
7. Not on my Side - Cameron Mcgill - 3 (G=14.5/4)
"Too folk-songish."
8. Friday Night at the Drive-In Bingo - Jens Lekman - 4 (K=13.5/4)
"I like the beat...could understand most of the words. It was a happy song."
9. A King and Queen - Okkervil River - 4 (K=17.5/5)
G: "Shocking!" Mom: "Why? I enjoyed it." [G didn't think it was poppy enough]
10. Buildings & Mountains - The Republic Tigers - 3.5 (G=18/5)
"I was going to give it a 4, but the instrumentality at the beginning and end went on too long."
11. Lights Out - Santogold - 3 (K=20.5/6)
Mom: "reminds me of someone else."
Dad: "wasn't this in a commercial somewhere?" [Yes: the Bud Light Lime ads this past summer]
12. Keep Me On - Bodies of Water - 2.5 (K=23/7)
Mom: "It was a very dreary song, but I liked some of the guitar parts and I pictured the people in all black clothing drearing along"
Dad: "It was a dirge"
13. Auctioneer - The Broken West - 3.5 (A's filler song)
Mom: "It was happy"
Dad: "It wasn't slow and they weren't in black"
14. Parties in the USA - Jonathan Richman - 5 (K=28/8)
"I'm torn...ok, a 5! I enjoyed the familiarity of it"
15. Always a Friend - Alejandro Escovedo - 5 (G=23/6)
"I liked that song...it reminded me of Huey Lewis and the News"
16. John Saw That Number - Neko Case - 2.5 (K=30.5/9)
"2.5...too twangy. The beginning reminded me of my least favorite part of "O, Brother Where Art Thou?" down by the river with the muses and those sirens. But, it had a good beat."
17. You Came Around - Nico Stai - 3.5 (G=26.5/7)
Mom: "3.5"
G: "It's not over yet."
Mom: "oh"..."Yes, 3.5. Here's what I say: if they're playing it live, people will start clapping because they think the song is over."
Dad: "The music was louder than the words." (a brief discussion/argument about bass/treble levels followed)
18. Foux du Fafa - Flight of the Conchords - 2.5 (K=33/10)
"Soup du jour? It was hard to sing along to, but I liked the music."
19. Hitten - Those Dancing Days - 3 (G=29.5/8)
"Umm, 3. It had a good beat, you could dance to it." [a car from hawaii almost caused 2 accidents during this song]
Intermission: Mom: "I generally prefer songs by guys, and not a lot of pre and post instrumental."
20. Why Do You Let Me Stay Here? - She and Him - 5 (G=34.5/9)
"I liked that song (I know I just contradicted myself)"
21. Keep Sending Me Black Fireworks - Of Montreal - 3 (K=36/11)
"Too many changes in the tempo, it was alright. Parts I didn't like but I liked the chorus."
22. Walking on a Dream - Empire of The Sun - 2.5 (G=37/10)
At the start of the song: K: "whoa" G: "Yeah, I'm not sure how this is gonna do."
...
Mom: "2.5"
G: "Better than I thought!"
23. Darling Be Here - Bodies of Water - 2.5 (K=38.5/12)
"This was an angry black Paso Doble song. Was that the same group [as earlier]?"
G: "You were lucky to get 2.5 out of that song."
Mom (Later): "It reminded me of Warren Sapp in black leather stomping around." [another Dancing With The Stars reference]
24. White Winter Hymnal - Fleet Foxes - 2.5 (K=41/13)
"Hmm...that was just an average song. Maybe the one before it should've been lower."
25. Would You - Richard Swift - 5 (G=42/11)
Dad: "I knew she'd like that song." Mom: "It sounded like Little Anthony and the Imperials."
26. Airline to Heaven - Wilco - 4 (K=45/14)
"Bob Dylan-ish. It grew on me."
27. Born to be Your Man - Birdmonster - 3 (G=45/12)
"Easy to understand the words, but I heard something about blood and when your uncle died."
28. I Stand Corrected - Vampire Weekend - 3 (G=48/13)
"I say 3"
29. Life is Long - David Byrne & Brian Eno - 5 (Selected by both K & G, so not counted in totals)
"easy to sing along with" Mom to Dad: "Do you agree with me most of the time on these songs?"
Dad: "nope."
30. Neverending Math Equation- Sun Kil Moon - 3.5 (G=51.5/14)
"Better than some, not as good as others."
Final Score (14 songs counted for each):
G - 51.5 total - 3.68 average
K - 45 total - 3.21 average
G wins for the second year in a row...I pretty much got destroyed.
Recap:
Songs with that "Motown" sound generally score very well (see: Jamie Lidell, Jonathan Richman, & Richard Swift). We have also learned that Mom prefers: male vocals, intelligible lyrics, shorter & less instrumental songs, and a general lack of dissonance.
Both G and I took more risks than last year, with varying results (but more fun!). My stubborn love for Bodies of Water didn't do me any favors, although there was a track mixup involved, and I was only supposed to have one of their tracks on my selections. My fault, but it wouldn't have made a difference. G put Empire of the Sun's "Walking on a Dream" on the mix for a laugh, fully expecting it to score a 2 or below, we were pleasantly surprised with the 2.5 it received.
I seriously expected higher scores out of Raphael Saadiq, Neko Case, Flight of the Conchords, Mates of State & Fleet Foxes. Oh well, 0/2...and another year we didn't have to listen to my mom's music for 3 hours.