“What's that background noise, it's all windy and shit and it sounds like the music is blowing my sorry ass around like some magic breeze of balls out indie rock typhoon extravaganza. How do you make recorded music sound like this." - Pavement Ist Rad
#6.

Deerhunter - Microcastle / Weird Era Cont. (4356 Points, 64 Votes, Three #1 Votes)US Chart Position: n/a
UK Chart Position: n/a
Charting Singles: n/a
SOMB Says: Deerhunter’s last album,
Cryptograms, was an unforgiving blend of ambient chillout, punk rock, and bursts of noise. Deerhunter’s latest album,
Microcastle, eschews these more esoteric elements and instead is a surprisingly confident and capable mix of astonishingly clear production, concise songwriting, and catchy melodies. Any active fan of the band could have seen this move coming; lead singer and songwriter Bradford Cox’s solo project betrayed his penchant for ambient and electronic washes cut with an ever-emerging sense of melody and lyricism. But the real surprise here is not its poppiness, nor the fact that the newfound pop sense works; it’s rather that, seemingly overnight, Deerhunter, the band that once swallowed up its admittedly pop songs in impenetrable walls of fuzz, reverb, and delay, have become masters of subtlety and detail. Where the band used to stumble through their own songs, haphazardly switching from one style to another, they now present us with a fantastic album of carefully written, meticulously recorded and perfectly produced 3-minute (on average) songs. These lean pop songs are just as ambitious as any of the band’s previous work, but instead of the songs and their outsized elements spilling all over each other, each song here is fully in its own little universe, with a clear progression, development, and resolution. Initially underwhelming, excruciatingly slow tracks like
Little Kids and the title track prove themselves to be wealths of detail, songs that start from almost nothing and end with perfectly natural, thunderous climaxes.
Microcastle never feels predictable or forced, and the band manages to fit decades of ‘indie’ music into single songs. Much has been made of the growing 4AD influence on Cox (culminating in himself and his band actually signing to the label), and it would be difficult to deny this influence here – it’s not hard to imagine Microcastle as a classic 4AD masterpiece next to
Head over Heels, Dead Can Dance, Prayers On Fire and
Surfer Rosa, and there aren’t many better compliments than that. But what makes it distinct from just another exercise in indie nostalgia is that no 4AD release* ever contained the swaying sexual deviance of
Agoraphobia, the achingly slow release of the title track, the ferocious Pixies-as-shoegaze stomp of
Never Stops, the simple classicist noir
Twilight At Carbon Lake, the creepy, sparse, and sluggish
Calvary Scars suite, or the Krautrock motorik juggernaut of the fantastic
Nothing Ever Happened, all in one package. Hell, even the woozy, one-minute-long introductory instrumental is one of the most beautiful, memorable tracks of the year. With
Microcastle, Deerhunter provides us with a world where there is no genre segregation, where opposing styles and influences clash and collide randomly, yet carefully – and it never feels unnatural – and a world where the little pop songs are meatier than any comparable pretentious, masturbatory excursions. With
Microcastle, Deerhunter has achieved perfection in the most insidious, unassuming way possible.
And then there’s
Weird Era Continued. As if sensing the band’s ever-apparent ‘recession’ into superficially less-challenging material, Cox and his band set out to create an entirely new album to package with
Microcastle, part defensive statement, part response to an early leak of the album.
Weird Era is like Microcastle’s retarded little brother, completely lacking the focus, clarity, or melody of its poppy counterpart; but it is not simply a laboured retread into
Cryptograms territory, as some might think – it is rather a further descent in experimentation that neither feels forced or pretentious. We get short loops of guitar delay, circular and confusing vocal tracks, and a few tracks that sound like the band pressed the wrong button on the mixing board. It doesn’t make sense, and it sounds rushed, but it feels right. The presence of this extra album is certainly welcomed, but also wholly unnecessary;
Microcastle is a fine statement on its own. The presence of
Weird Era, and its prowess at doing the exact opposite of what the band worked hard to achieve on
Microcastle, only cements the status of this band as an impressively dynamic force.
*Although several Birthday Party releases certainly came close. -
Heretix Artist's Previous Rankings on Our Albums Lists: “Cryptograms” (#23 of 2007)
Ranked Highest By: Heretix, washing machine, Lewis (#1)
Also Ranked By: Badger, elementus attacks! (#2), Mike N., greekgoat91, killerparties, Plate, undo (#3), Nick, cpl-593h (#4), arkin, Waterloo, liquidheaven, johnny largesax, RustyTrombone, Drinky, UselessRocker (#5)
Amazon Link