QUOTE (Montana @ Oct 27 2009, 04:23 AM)

QUOTE (lurker @ Oct 26 2009, 04:02 PM)

I'm sure it was...I heard some boots and enjoyed them quite a bit. But there's huge chunks where Waters is just playing bass, while the backing band takes the lead on parts originally played/sung by Gilmour and Wright...and I missed hearing the actual guys doing it.
Yes, an unfortunate issue. Waters wanted to tour after Live 8 with the full band, Gilmour said no. So blame Gilmour for that.
Well...I can't really do that. I can't blame a guy who doesn't want to spend months of his life touring with a guy who was a dick for decades who suddenly decides "Hey, I wanna join the band again. And (probably) take over again." As much as I would have loved to have seen it, I can't blame someone in their 60's wanting to relax at home with his family and, when he DOES want to tour, preferring to do it with people he actually enjoys being around.
There's a lot of blame to go around really...
QUOTE
However, the show was still outstanding, but there's no doubt there were sections where you were like "we need Dave here". The same was said for the PULSE tour about Roger(Guy Pratt's bass playing is way too clinical).
This is true.
But, to me, although Roger was responsible for the concept of DSOTM and the lyrics and all that, I think the overall SOUND of the record comes more from Dave and Rick. And if you HAD to have one half of the band performing it without the other, that's the half I would take. Whereas with The Wall I'd obviously have to go with Roger...but, of course, it would be best to have all of them. But that's just never gonna happen again unfortunately