Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: rhcp
Sound Opinions Message Board > Music Related > Music Discussion
swede
expecting the worst, but am anticipating this release, mainly out of curiosity...
was a big fan of Mother's Milk
anyway...

track listing for the new album "I'm With You" from the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

'Monarchy Of Roses'
'Factory Of Faith'
'Brendan's Death Song'
'Ethiopia'
'Annie Wants A Baby'
'Look Around'
'The Adventures Of Rain Dance Maggie'
'Did I Let You Know'
'Goodbye Hooray'
'Happiness Loves Company'
'Police Station'
'Even You Brutus?'
'Meet Me At The Corner'
'Dance, Dance, Dance'

It is set to be released on August 29th.
Pat Sansone
Who's playing guitar on this?
spiritofeden
Does that even matter at this point?
swede
Josh Klinghoffer
elementus
I'm anticipating this being worse than One Hot Minute.
Ned
QUOTE (elementus @ Jun 16 2011, 09:05 PM) *
I'm anticipating this being worse than One Hot Minute.


This was actually the last Chili Peppers record I sort of liked.
the dude
wow how i hate this band.
Pavement Ist Rad
Can't wait to hear what insane shit Flea came up w/ for this!
badger5000
QUOTE (swede @ Jun 17 2011, 03:10 AM) *
'Monarchy Of Roses'
'Factory Of Faith'
'Brendan's Death Song'
'Ethiopia'
'Annie Wants A Baby'
'Look Around'
'The Adventures Of Rain Dance Maggie'
'Did I Let You Know'
'Goodbye Hooray'
'Happiness Loves Company'
'Police Station'
'Even You Brutus?'
'Meet Me At The Corner'
'Dance, Dance, Dance'


If those songs don't all clock in around 2.5 minutes then this album is going to be way too long.

This album is going to be way too long.
Ned
The Adventures of Rain Dance Maggie sounds like it could be the title to an awesome late 80s Chili Peppers song. It'll probably not be so groovy in 2011 tho.
Pygmy
I've actually enjoyed a lot of the new stuff. The best of is actually pretty listenable, almost in a new Smashing Pumpkins kind of guilty pleasure way. Again, like the SP, I don't give a fuck about this band enough to feel cheated by their new material. As a result I usually enjoy it for a month or two.
Angrimorfee
This band, along with the B52s, is an artist for whom I would not despair never hearing again.
the dude
their last several albums have been bloated corporate dreck for the masses.

this band ranks alongside foo fighters and smashing pumpkins as an embarrassment to themselves.
twicks
QUOTE (Pygmy @ Jun 17 2011, 07:08 AM) *
I've actually enjoyed a lot of the new stuff. The best of is actually pretty listenable, almost in a new Smashing Pumpkins kind of guilty pleasure way. Again, like the SP, I don't give a fuck about this band enough to feel cheated by their new material. As a result I usually enjoy it for a month or two.



At this point I mostly admire them for 1) being in the game so long and still lodging actual hit songs, and 2) having a Herculean work effort when it comes to writing. Pretty sure they write a Stadium Arcadium amount of tunes for every record and edit them down, except for that one (obvs).

But man, can't they change up their production style even a smidge? The last three records all sound like they were recorded at the same freaking session. I blame Rick Rubin.

C.I.
really hope dance dance dance is a neil young cover
ryan
QUOTE (C.I. @ Jun 17 2011, 10:09 AM) *
really hope dance dance dance is a neil young cover

nah, steve miller band.
maztrax
I simply cannot think of a bigger band that douchebags flock to than RHCP in 2011.
Pat Sansone
I could think of a few.
Pygmy
QUOTE (maztrax @ Jun 17 2011, 01:38 PM) *
I simply cannot think of a bigger band that douchebags flock to than RHCP in 2011.


I don't agree, maybe Nickleback and Linkin Park for crap-rock douchebaggery.

Whereas Indie Douchbags flock to whatever NPR is playing.

RHCP are somewhere along side U2, SP, Cure etc. in the category of washed up but still putting in a decent effort. Most of the love for them now is centered around nostalgia not douchebaggery.
UselessRocker
RHCP are kinda like Foo Fighters. They've never really descended into making awful records, just forgettable ones that follow a certain formula. I own Stadium Arcadium and I never listen to it. It's not shitty. It's just that it all blurs together in a big blah ball of what they've been doing for twenty years. Proof of that is that when I saw The Fighter and heard the RHCP song in that one scene, I thought "Hey, this is a decent little RHCP song" and it turned out I already owned the damn thing and had all but blocked it from memory.
twicks
QUOTE (UselessRocker @ Jun 17 2011, 03:21 PM) *
RHCP are kinda like Foo Fighters. They've never really descended into making awful records, just forgettable ones that follow a certain formula. I own Stadium Arcadium and I never listen to it. It's not shitty. It's just that it all blurs together in a big blah ball of what they've been doing for twenty years. Proof of that is that when I saw The Fighter and heard the RHCP song in that one scene, I thought "Hey, this is a decent little RHCP song" and it turned out I already owned the damn thing and had all but blocked it from memory.



Seriously. The last 3 albums are good...and totally interchangeable in every way. There's no real filler, it all reaches a fairly high level of quality. But because the production is exactly the same, it just all blends together.
plaid

According to wikipedia

"Flea said that the Rolling Stones albums Exile On Main Street and Tattoo You were major influences on the new music and he listened to both albums often during the writing of the album."


I had incredibly low expectations for this album before reading this, but now it seems like it might be end up being kind of awesome. also Josh Klinghoffer is no joke and should not be underestimated, but oh yeah, Anthony Keidis still sings for the band......

twicks
QUOTE (plaid @ Jun 19 2011, 11:29 PM) *
According to wikipedia

"Flea said that the Rolling Stones albums Exile On Main Street and Tattoo You were major influences on the new music and he listened to both albums often during the writing of the album."


I had incredibly low expectations for this album before reading this, but now it seems like it might be end up being kind of awesome. also Josh Klinghoffer is no joke and should not be underestimated, but oh yeah, Anthony Keidis still sings for the band......


I'm just happy Tattoo You is being acknowledged as a stone freakin' classic. I like that album even more than Exile.
plaid

The Tattoo You inspired basslines I am imagining in my head that Flea will come up with are totally awesome.


Chronodiggity
QUOTE (UselessRocker @ Jun 17 2011, 12:21 PM) *
It's not shitty. It's just that it all blurs together in a big blah ball of what they've been doing for twenty years.


At some point these two become the same thing and I think Stadium Arcadium was exactly that point
Midnite_Vulture
These guys used to be one of my favorite bands from 4th-8th grade. Even stuck with them through By The Way, which I felt had about 4 or 5 quality tunes. Stadium Arcadium was where they lost me and I haven't been able to quite call myself a fan since. I'd honestly like for them to create something worthwhile again since they were so integral to me getting heavily in to music and their past discography is pretty solid, but the news of an upcoming release just leaves me with a sense of apathy. I'm really not looking forward to the day where I have to tell everyone, "Oh, I'm too cool to listen to the Chili Peppers."
spiritofeden
QUOTE (twicks @ Jun 19 2011, 11:33 PM) *
I'm just happy Tattoo You is being acknowledged as a stone freakin' classic. I like that album even more than Exile.

WTF???!!
velocity
Never got into this band, except to admire Flea's technique. Still, the prospect of listening to a new album from them is magnitudes more appealing than, say, something new from GNR or Aerosmith. Or the planned abomination by Lou Reed & Metallica.
UselessRocker
I really think that Frusciante getting bored and leaving is a big "uh oh" for this band.

Liffey
Love Stadium Arcadium pretty much all the way through, only a couple clunkers on that one, and several brilliant tracks. Really looking forward to the new one.
the dude
this band manages to suck and blow simultaneously.

quite the achievement.
petras
I thought Stadium Arcadium was a bit long by 5 or 6 songs but otherwise solid. By The Way was brilliant and Californication was not far off. I'm not sure much can be made of Frusciente getting bored and leaving the band, that dudes a little wacked.
twicks
As feared, this is pretty lame sans Frusciante:

http://www.spin.com/articles/listen-red-ho...pers-bring-funk
solace
QUOTE (twicks @ Jul 18 2011, 12:04 PM) *
As feared, this is pretty lame sans Frusciante:

http://www.spin.com/articles/listen-red-ho...pers-bring-funk


it's awful but not simply cuz of the lack of Frusciante (the solo is one of the better parts)
plaid


chad smith looks like such a tool in this photo.

also what is anthony kiedis doing?

Gluehead
More boring than church.
plaid
QUOTE (twicks @ Jul 18 2011, 01:04 PM) *
As feared, this is pretty lame sans Frusciante:

http://www.spin.com/articles/listen-red-ho...pers-bring-funk


yeah actually klinghoffer's contributions are the best part of this. the noisy solo break is pretty gnarly.

kiedis is in self parody territory, and the "scissor beat" is pretty forced and generic, like an approximation of how they think they need to sound in 2011 where indie dance music is a cool thing with the kids. i like the layered percussion at the end with the snakey guitar line. the last 45 seconds of this are the best. that's how the song should have started.



b*derty
QUOTE (Pygmy @ Jun 17 2011, 12:17 PM) *
QUOTE (maztrax @ Jun 17 2011, 01:38 PM) *
I simply cannot think of a bigger band that douchebags flock to than RHCP in 2011.


I don't agree, maybe Nickleback and Linkin Park for crap-rock douchebaggery.

Whereas Indie Douchbags flock to whatever NPR is playing.

RHCP are somewhere along side U2, SP, Cure etc. in the category of washed up but still putting in a decent effort. Most of the love for them now is centered around nostalgia not douchebaggery.

lets not bring the cure into this dry.gif
their last few might not of been as good disintegration or kiss me... but at least they're trying new things.
4:13 dream is a masterpiece when you compare it to Stadium Arcadium
the dude
this song sucks and it's no surprise - the band making it have blown chunks for well over a decade. over two if you think mother's milk was the last thing they did of any quality.
theremin
QUOTE (the dude @ Jul 19 2011, 06:47 AM) *
this song sucks and it's no surprise - the band making it have blown chunks for well over a decade. over two if you think mother's milk was the last thing they did of any quality.


Actually, in two months those of us that think Blood Sugar Sex Magik was the last thing will have been waiting over 2 decades also.
twicks
QUOTE (theremin @ Jul 19 2011, 01:16 PM) *
QUOTE (the dude @ Jul 19 2011, 06:47 AM) *
this song sucks and it's no surprise - the band making it have blown chunks for well over a decade. over two if you think mother's milk was the last thing they did of any quality.


Actually, in two months those of us that think Blood Sugar Sex Magik was the last thing will have been waiting over 2 decades also.



Funny, because I'm increasingly of the opinion that the last 3 albums with Frusciante are the best things they've ever done.

I was listening to Mother's Milk the other day. Those earlier records are charming, sure, but it's schticky as hell and way too self-referential for my tastes.

Pavement Ist Rad
I simply cannot see that argument being made if you're insisting on throwing in Stadium Arcadium.

The two before it, maybe, although I don't agree. It's not totally unreasonable, though.
plaid

i completely stand behind everything about Stadium Arcadium sans anthony kiedis' contributions. the production and guitar work/band interplay on that album is seriously awesome. it is spoiled only by some 40 year old dude singing shit like "you try to be a lady but you're walkin' like a sour kraut." if john sang on the whole album and wrote all the lyrics it would be one of my favorite albums of the decade.



Duff.
QUOTE (plaid @ Jul 18 2011, 12:08 PM) *


chad smith looks like such a tool in this photo.

also what is anthony kiedis doing?

These guys have been looking like assholes in photographs their entire existence.
Ned
QUOTE (Gluehead @ Jul 18 2011, 09:22 AM) *
More boring than church.

You gotta start going to the crazy black churches like in the blues brothers. Those negros get down!!
twicks
Only one listen in...but I'm digging it.

If you told me Frusciante played on this thing, I'd probably believe you. Only major difference is in the solos.
Pygmy
I like about 3 songs on the album. They could be described as the most "Californication-y Songs" the rest is terrible. I've liked allot of their new stuff, not loved, but I'm okay with just liking it. This one doesn't have the same strength in the melodies. This album relies too heavily on vocals and drums and that doesn't cut it for me on a RHCP album. Though, I will say the drumming on this album is the best they've done in some time.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.