I caught this last night at the Music Box and it's certainly a different one.
The little girl is amazing, and the mood and the look of the movie (innocent/grotesque/childlike/creepy) is really impressive and effective, but it ends up going too far for my tastes. There's just too much "unpleasantness" (to steal Jonothan Rosenbaum's phrasing) to sit through without an apparent point.
I'm a pretty big Gilliam fan, but I would recommend skipping this one unless you really want to sit through some disturbing shit. Gilliam's (hilarious) disclaimer before the movie was helpful for keeping me in the perspective of the
characters for the most part, but at times I was taken out of the movie because I couldn't help but feel bad for what the little
actress had to go through. I think that a lot about kid actors in weird movies; maybe I'm just a wuss about that sort of thing.
Definitely not a date movie.
EDIT: I'm now in the middle of a discussion on another board that is helping me see that there are some pretty remarkable things about this movie if I look past the parts that bothered me.