QUOTE(crease @ Mar 1 2006, 08:18 AM) [snapback]32164[/snapback]
man, totally disagree. redux >>>>>> the original. the film breathes more easily in the extended cut.
I heard they completely re-edited the movie, so there may be different takes/shots and different cuts, but I didn't really notice much of a difference outside of the added scenes. I think I'm missing one scene, possibly two, but for the most part, you get:
more about the napalm ruining the surf and a bit more story about Willard stealing Kilgore's surfboard
trading diesel for the Playmates
the long French plantation sequence (confrontation in the fog + burial + meal + bed scene)
Kurtz reading old articles (during and after LBJ) from Time magazine suggesting that the war's going well
The added surf segments are okay, amusing, but stick out a bit too much.
The scene with the Playmates didn't really work for me. There is something interesting about Chef being so enthralled by the image projected by Miss December (actually Miss May, but he keeps thinking she's Miss December) in the magazine than the woman herself - the wig, the pose, etc., but the sequence as a whole is pretty shakey.
The plantation sequence was just tedious, especially the meal. A tiny bit was in the documentary ("Heart of Darkness"?) on the making of this picture, and it seemed interesting in that context, but I think they cut out some narration that was used for the doc but not Redux - something about these people being ghosts clinging on to a colonial past. What's left seems to go on forever. The burial wasn't interesting and somewhat superfluous (I never found myself asking "What happened to so-and-so's body?" in the original).
Brando seems stiff and uninterested in the Time magazine scene, which still doesn't fix the film's ending.