QUOTE(partyboatmelvin @ Nov 28 2006, 10:53 PM) [snapback]254353[/snapback]
The scenes with Brando are spectacular. They only cut him out to save money. Geez, studios! Anyway, as a movie I don't think "The Donner Cut" works. There's just too much that is incomplete; but if you are a fan, I'd rent it just to see the Brando stuff. Also, I should note that Margot Kidder is quite fetching in the Donner scenes and a lot spunkier.
I finally watched this tonight, and I agree with yer analysis. There's a lot of neat things revealed, but there's an astonishingly high amount of chemistry missing between the characters. I never thought I'd see this film released, and now that I have, I am a bit disappointed. Of course, I'm thrilled they didn't try to simply "tweak" the film via CGI (a'la
Star Wars/Star Trek) - they literally revamped the entire film (for more info,
click here). But it's really jumpy in detail + character development, which results in a film that's not nearly as warm as Lester's version. Still, it's got some killer sequences thrown into the mix, Christopher Reeve + Margot Kidder show some of their dramatic chops, and they did a great job matching the color temperatures + soundtrack from the various footage.
I've been saying for years that Lester improved on donner's original film in every way. Heck I think I prefer Lester's Superman 3 to the original. That 'turning back time' shit was just the essence of cop-out.