QUOTE(theremin @ Dec 14 2007, 12:46 PM) [snapback]530169[/snapback]
Personally, I'd like to hear one good reason why Will Smith isn't up for an Oscar. A reason that doesn't start with S and end with nobs.
For years this remake was in development as an Arnold Schwarzenegger vehicle, its backers surely hoping for some of that 'Terminator 2' box office magic. I suspect such magic may elude the film that came to pass. But Smith carries it, even after the story loses its nerve. This film is the opposite of 'Transformers': It's all about the unsettling silence, not the noise. (Michael Phillips)
Smith is a true movie star: He could stand alone before the camera reciting those page-long drug ad disclaimers, and still command our attention. (Stephen Rea)
He may be a little perky to play Earth's loneliest man, but he's more than convincing as Hollywood's nicest guy. (Dana Stevens)
Unfortunately, "I Am Legend" squanders Will Smith's least bombastic, most subtle and restrained performance with shockingly silly, not-at-all-scary special effects (Micahel Machosky)
edit-not to suggest that I'm not curious to see this followup to the directors last outing, 'Constantine' but I'm not getting the overwhelming feeling that his performance matched the quality of the movie. It's certainly not bad reviews but then it's in this apocalyptic/horror/scifi genre that doesn't usually have a lot of crossover audiences.