Did I cover the portion you found to be a spoiler?
Anyway, I clearly didn't explain myself well. I wasn't surprised to see the end result with Bale's character, you're right, Nolan did try to set that up the "whole time", which is where I thought the film failed-
Spoiler/NSFW: click to show/hide
it was intended to make my sympathize with Bale, and I didn't. So I didn't think the film itself was successful.
I guess I'm confused as to why you found it incredible- you weren't looking for a big surprise, so what did you find to be so fantastic in the film? I didn't personally find the performances of the two leads to be strong, but disregarding that, if you enjoy the film as a performance piece, I wouldn't think that'd rank it as "incredible." Such as, I enjoy
Lions for Lambs largely due to its performances, and while I may argue that this makes it a good film, I wouldn't say that makes it an incredible one. If you particularly enjoyed the writing, that's another thing, but I suppose what I'm asking, is what absorbed you so entirely? The film was considered a thriller, and by your own admission of its lacking surprise, and immediate openness about the lack of shocks coming...what grasped you? I found the film to be kind of empty. Style, but little gripping substance.
I obviously also didn't find the writing strong, due to
Spoiler/NSFW: click to show/hide
my never developing sympathy for Bale
, despite the writer's clear intention that I should. Then again, maybe that's my shortcoming. I discussed the film with my old film professor, and he had the same complaint about the film, for what little that's worth. (I know it's tiresome to throw out the "oh, my film prof said...", sorry for that one) I've come to dislike Bale, but when the film was released/I saw it, I was impartial, so I don't think that's what affected me.