QUOTE(Philoctetes @ Dec 6 2006, 07:04 PM) [snapback]261368[/snapback]
Man, you guys are harsh. I thought for sure that the early feedback would be positive, given that the debut was generally so well-received.
live by the blog, die by the blog.
QUOTE(Philoctetes @ Dec 6 2006, 07:04 PM) [snapback]261368[/snapback]
Interesting, cuz I think my affair is finally coming to an end. I still think that Shut Up I Am Dreaming is a great record (one of the best of '06, in fact), but the more i go back and listen to it, to more disenchanted i become.
for real? i hadn't listened to it for a couple months, and the first time i played it, ending the hiatus, from the first song, it held me. "i'm sorry that anybody dies" is one of the truest lines from one of the truest openings ever. and each song, though overlong perhaps, fades beautifully into the next, up until the ending which is completely, absolutely satisfying. i can't think of an indie album which has been more heartfelt. ever. it isn't that accessible, but once the ice is broken, i think it's a lifelong love, lifelong burden.